Top Home Bottom

The NZMeccano 10-set survey results

The NZMeccano 10-set survey is available here. If you are the fortunate owner of one of Meccano's largest outfits, please tell us about it by going to that page!

This page shows some of the results of our 10-set survey, from the live data collected so far.

If you can think of other information you would like to see (from the data we retrieved), please make a comment at the bottom of this page and we'll see whether it can be added!

The survey was launched on 7th September 2009, and the results to date are as follows:

Overall data set

So far, 540 people have filled in the survey form, describing 1219 complete outfits.  These people have an average of 2.26 outfits each!

The outfits described are as follows:

All outfits, grouped by outfit number

Outfit 10	615
Outfit 9+9A	102
Outfit 7	74
Outfit 6+6a	71
Outfit 6	70
Outfit L	65
Box E	63
Outfit K+Ka	57

And here's where all the outfits are located:

All outfits, grouped by location

UK	309
Australia	80
New Zealand	66
Rest of Europe	53
Canada	48
USA	47
South Africa	20
Rest of world	14
Asia	6
South America	5
France	3

Here's what people do with their 10-sets:

Outfits 10 and 9+9A only, grouped by how they are used

I build models	252
I keep it in a box	168
In my building stock	121
Undecided	118
Something else	38

Looking only at the 10-sets, the colour schemes are as follows:

Outfits 10 and 9+9A only, grouped by colour

Medium red/green	235
Blue/yellow/zinc	163
Light red/green	79
French blue/yellow/zinc	62
Dark blue/Dark yellow	29
Zinc/yellow/black	28
Silver/yellow/black	25
Blue/gold	25
Other or mixed	22
Dark red/dark green	16
French blue/gold	10
Blue/gold/green	10
Nickel plated	9

Meccano Builders results

If we limit ourselves to the Meccano 'builders', those who have said that they build models with their 10-sets or who have split the parts up into their building stock, we can split up the analysis by colour scheme. In the following graph, the builders are in red and the collectors are in green:

All 10 (or 9+9A) outfits grouped by colour, showing those used for building (red) and collecting (green)

Medium red/green	117 118 235
Blue/yellow/zinc	113 50 163
Light red/green	35 44 79
French blue/yellow/zinc	33 29 62
Dark blue/Dark yellow	7 22 29
Zinc/yellow/black	16 12 28
Silver/yellow/black	12 13 25
Blue/gold	10 15 25
Other or mixed	15 7 22
Dark red/dark green	4 12 16
French blue/gold	5 5 10
Blue/gold/green	10 10
Nickel plated	5 4 9

Collectors' outfits

George asked me to show the colour distribution of 'show' outfits, those that are in really super condition and are true survivors. To qualify for this, we need to look at only those outfits that are in better than 'excellent' condition, with at least the original cabinet, were manufactured by Meccano, and aren't used for building models. The colour schemes break down like this:

Meccano-made 10 or 9+9A outfits, in better than excellent condition, with cabinet, manuals, and parts boxes

Medium red/green	29
Light red/green	16
French blue/yellow/zinc	13
Blue/yellow/zinc	12
Dark blue/Dark yellow	9
Silver/yellow/black	5
Zinc/yellow/black	5
Blue/gold/green	3
Blue/gold	1
French blue/gold	1
Dark red/dark green	1
Nickel plated	1

As expected, the 'classic' medium red/green presentation cabinet is the most common, as it is seen as the definitive No.10 set, even by Meccanomen who were brought up on later colour schemes.

• 899 outfits (73.7%) are in an original cabinet or box
• 652 outfits (53.5%) are in a reproduction cabinet
• 958 outfits (78.6%) have all their manuals
• 786 outfits (64.5%) have their small parts boxes
• 640 outfits (52.5%) have their original stringing cards
• 557 outfits (45.7%) have dust sheets or shrinkwrapping
• 534 outfits (43.8%) have their outer packing carton
• 610 outfits (50.0%) have a key!

How did we find them?

So, where do people buy their large Meccano outfits? Here's an analysis of the source of outfits, broken down into those outfits bought before 2000 (in red) and since 2000 (in green):

All Meccano outfits, by source, showing pre-2000 (red) and 2000 onwards (green) purchases

Through eBay	1 84 85
From a dealer	38 37 75
Club member	17 21 38
Some other way	15 16 31
Toy auction	16 11 27
Classified	16 10 26
Bought new	25 1 26
From a lucky contact	9 12 21
Friend	6 15 21
It was a present	14 2 16
Spanner	1 14 15
Inherited	4 6 10
Other internet site	3 6 9
Can't remember	1 1

No surprises here, with eBay taking over as the primary source of Meccano outfits in the last decade. Meccano club members, friends, and Spanners make up the most common sources for more recently purchased outfits. What this chart does show us is that a large proportion of outfits have changed hands in the last few years.

Note that outfits where there was no purchase date, or no source information, are not shown in this chart.

Further breakdown of outfits

Let's have a look at all of the outfits now (of any size), and see how many are original and how many have been 'built up' from either spare parts or over a gradual period through various stages. The original outfits are in red, the built up ones in green:

All Meccano outfits, by colour, showing original (red) and built-up (green) outfits

Medium red/green	114 117 231
Blue/yellow/zinc	88 70 158
Light red/green	40 34 74
French blue/yellow/zinc	35 26 61
Dark blue/Dark yellow	21 19 40
Nickel plated	15 21 36
Dark red/dark green	16 19 35
Silver/yellow/black	18 17 35
Blue/gold	20 14 34
Zinc/yellow/black	19 11 30
Other or mixed	5 21 26
Blue/gold/green	4 12 16
French blue/gold	5 8 13

As expected, the most common 'built up' outfit by far is the medium red/green. Original nickel outfits surprisingly show only one entry. The unusual 'mixed colour' original outfit is an export one which was supplied in a mixture of medium red/green and light red/green.

Let's break down the outfits in the same way – red for original and green for built-up:

All Meccano outfits, by outfit number, showing original (red) and built-up (green) outfits

Outfit 10	296 319 615
Outfit 9+9A	36 66 102
Outfit 7	18 56 74
Outfit 6+6a	10 61 71
Outfit 6	13 57 70
Outfit L	14 51 65
Box E	3 60 63
Outfit K+Ka	6 51 57

Comments

Total number of messages on this page: 16.  This is page 1 of 3.   

Claude Lepage      (at 4:15pm, Mon 15th Jul, 24)

I own a 10 outfit in its origanl wooden box and parts for at least two other 10 outfits. clmagnicourt&sfr.fr 118 rue d'Assas F-75006 PARIS FRANCE

Kegan      (at 5:03am, Mon 15th Feb, 21)

Added my early 50s one -#500! =)

bob t      (at 10:52pm, Sun 3rd May, 20)

Ashley, There are quite a few new and old ModelPlans based on a No. 10 set

Ashley Lamb      (at 10:28pm, Sun 3rd May, 20)

How relevant is a 10 set to a keen Meccano builder in 2020 ? The special models are rather old fashioned and "clunky" has the internet and "Constructor Quarterly" become the source of new models to build.?

Richard      (at 9:45am, Thu 8th Dec, 16)

Vic, Click on the Outfits tab at the top of the page and you will see at the bottom of the list that pops up "Parts List Generator". Select the year and outfit size and a list of parts will be generated which you can copy into Excel or Word and then print off.

Vic Harrison      (at 8:21am, Thu 8th Dec, 16)

I have just bough a Set 10 privately through your site and it seems to be 99% all new parts. How can I check if it is 100% complete? Vic

Your name:
Your message:
Security check:	(Please type in the text to prove you're a person!)